Alia Bhatt says the box office is not her creative director. After the underwhelming theatrical runs of Jigra and Alpha, the actor told TIME magazine that she will continue choosing women-led stories, and she questioned why a male-led flop is rarely treated as a verdict on male-led films.
A double standard, stated plainly
Speaking after her inclusion in the TIME100 Next India list, Bhatt pushed back on the scrutiny that follows female-led projects. “When a male-led film flops, nobody says that we shouldn’t be making ‘male-centric’ films,” she said. “So I am not going to stop choosing films that are women-led.”
Bhatt described these choices as calculated risks: “When you take these gambles, you always risk falling flat on your face. But there’s an equally good chance that you might fly.” The framing matters in an industry where a single underperformance can harden into a rule about audience appetite.
The record behind the argument
The actor’s position is not a new one. Her filmography includes women-centred successes such as Raazi and Gangubai Kathiawadi, which became significant hits. It also includes setbacks—Shaandaar, her first box-office failure, and the later disappointment of Kalank—that Bhatt has discussed candidly across interviews.
Bhatt has lived both outcomes. In 2016 she told PTI that Shaandaar was her first box-office failure, and in 2022 she discussed with Galatta Plus how Kalank’s reception affected her. Rather than narrowing her choices, those setbacks were followed by more varied roles. That pattern is the strongest evidence behind her latest statement.
What changes now is the context:
- The wins: Raazi and Gangubai Kathiawadi showed that women-led stories can carry big commercial outcomes.
- The misses: Jigra underperformed theatrically, and Alpha arrived as a female-led action gamble in a genre that has not been consistent in India.
- The response: Bhatt’s instinct has been to widen her range rather than run to the safest script available.
While discussing Alpha with Femina, Bhatt had already accepted that a female-led action film was a gamble. Her latest TIME comments make clear that the result—good or bad—will not end the experiment.
Why the double standard matters
For Hindi cinema, the debate is bigger than one actor’s slate. Female-led films often carry the burden of proof: each failure is read as evidence about the category, while male-led failures rarely produce the same conclusion. Bhatt’s comment names that asymmetry. Whether audiences reward the next gamble remains to be seen, but the choice of films is no longer being made defensively.
Bhatt will next be seen in Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s Love & War, alongside Ranbir Kapoor and Vicky Kaushal.
Source: MissMalini





Comments